Maritime analysis. Real-time insight.

CII Ratings: Less Fuel Burned, More CO₂ per Cargo Tonne-Mile

Share this article


CII measures annual CO₂ emissions against vessel capacity and distance travelled, without accounting directly for actual cargo carried.

Two sister ships may finish the year with the same Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) rating despite carrying markedly different quantities of cargo. One may consume less fuel and achieve a better attained CII, yet produce considerably more CO₂ for every tonne of cargo actually transported. This is possible because the IMO calculation uses a vessel’s certified carrying capacity and distance travelled, without directly accounting for how much cargo was carried.

In commercial shipping, the quantity loaded is generally determined by the charterer’s nomination, cargo availability and port restrictions. A vessel may therefore sail partly laden even when additional carrying capacity is available. The resulting CII grade provides no direct measure of cargo utilisation, although it may subsequently influence assessments of the ship’s commercial and environmental performance.


What the CII calculation actually measures

Under MARPOL Annex VI, tankers, bulk carriers, container ships and several other cargo vessels generally use the Annual Efficiency Ratio (AER) to calculate their attained CII. Annual CO₂ emissions are divided by the vessel’s deadweight multiplied by the distance travelled, giving a result in grams of CO₂ per DWT-nautical mile. This figure is compared against the rating boundaries applicable to the ship’s type, size and reporting year to determine its A–E grade. Certain other vessel categories, including cruise passenger ships and some ro-ro vessels, use gross tonnage instead of deadweight.

Deadweight is a certified capacity figure that includes cargo, bunkers, fresh water and stores. It remains unchanged whether the vessel is fully laden, partly laden or in ballast. Subject to permitted regulatory adjustments, ballast miles contribute to the annual distance, while fuel consumed at sea, in port and at anchor adds to total emissions. Actual cargo quantity does not enter the AER calculation. Genuine improvements in fuel efficiency can still reduce attained CII, as examined in DeepDraft’s earlier analysis of engine air-intake efficiency.

The attained CII and its A–E rating are different: a lower attained value may remain within the same rating band. For 2026, required CII is 11% below the applicable 2019 reference line.

CII measures annual CO₂ emissions against vessel capacity and distance travelled, without directly accounting for cargo carried.

Two vessels with the same rating

Consider two hypothetical sister VLCCs of 300,000 DWT, each completing six laden passages of 6,000 nautical miles and six ballast passages of 4,000 nautical miles annually. One carries 280,000 tonnes per laden passage, while the other carries 150,000 tonnes. Assuming slightly lower fuel consumption for the lighter-loaded vessel, their annual performance can be compared using both the statutory CII and actual cargo transport work.

Illustrative 2026 ship-yearLarger parcelSmaller parcel
Cargo per laden passage280,000 t150,000 t
Annual distance60,000 nm60,000 nm
Annual fuel consumption12,000 t11,580 t
Annual CO₂ emissions 37,368 t36,060 t
Attained CII (g CO₂ / DWT-nm)2.0762.003
Modelled CII ratingCC
CO₂ per actual cargo tonne-mile3.707 g6.678 g

Methodology: The vessels are hypothetical. HFO emissions use a conversion factor of 3.114 tonnes CO₂ per tonne of fuel. Each rotation assumes 700 tonnes ballast fuel and 120 tonnes port/other consumption; laden fuel is 1,180 or 1,110 tonnes respectively. No CII adjustments apply. The 2026 required CII is approximately 2.129 (C band: 1.980–2.300). Fuel differences are assumed, without a vessel-specific speed-draught model.

The smaller-parcel vessel emits approximately 3.5% less CO₂ and achieves a better attained CII, although both receive the same C rating. However, its actual transport work is 5.40 billion cargo tonne-miles compared with 10.08 billion for the larger-parcel vessel. Applying the principle of IMO’s voluntary Energy Efficiency Operational Indicator (EEOI) over the full ship-year, using total annual CO₂ emissions divided by cargo tonne-miles performed during laden passages, the smaller-parcel operation produces approximately 80% more CO₂ per cargo tonne-mile. The cargo-based calculation includes emissions from ballast and port operations, although cargo transport work is counted only during laden passages. The comparison does not establish that either vessel was operated inefficiently, since cargo quantities may have been dictated by commercial requirements.

The issue extends to bulk carriers constrained by parcel size or draught, container ships carrying varying proportions of empty containers, and gas carriers subject to cargo-density and containment limits. A common cargo-based measure would need to account for the different ways these trades measure transport work.

A 2019 Sustainability study of four sister bulk carriers found that one ship had a better AER (6.14 versus 7.48) but worse EEOI (9.65 versus 8.87) than another. The limited 2018 voyage sample cannot establish fleet-wide prevalence, but confirms that capacity-based and cargo-based rankings can differ.

An unladen tanker sits high in the water, while its certified deadweight remains unchanged for CII calculations.

Reading this as a maritime insider, seafarer, or enthusiast?

Subscribe to The DeepDraft for maritime analysis, daily SITREP updates, weekly briefings, and operational signals worth watching.


Why IMO uses deadweight, and where the responsibility lies

IMO’s preference for deadweight has practical reasons. The original Data Collection System recorded fuel consumption, distance travelled and certified vessel particulars, without consistently collecting actual cargo quantities across different trades. Deadweight offered a fixed, verifiable denominator, avoiding the complications of examining cargo documents, multi-port operations and commercially sensitive information.

Replacing deadweight with actual cargo could introduce a different problem. A charterer may nominate a smaller parcel, while terminal restrictions or cargo availability may prevent a ship from loading to capacity. Assessing the vessel solely against actual cargo carried could therefore penalise efficient machinery and shipboard operations for circumstances outside the owner’s or Master’s control. Verification would also require consistent treatment of cargo records and ballast emissions, particularly where vessels reposition between unrelated cargoes.

The difficulty becomes more apparent when considering annual operations. Additional ballast steaming can improve the AER if its emissions per mile are below the existing annual average, even though total CO₂ increases. Prolonged port waiting has the opposite effect, adding emissions without corresponding distance. The owner, charterer, port and Master influence different parts of this outcome, making it difficult to attribute the final rating to any single party.

Loading limits constrain the cargo a vessel can carry, while CII uses its certified deadweight irrespective of the quantity actually loaded.

When CII becomes a commercial consideration

A poor CII rating has consequences beyond annual regulatory reporting. A vessel receiving an E rating, or a D rating for three consecutive years, must undertake corrective action through its SEEMP. Although neither grade automatically prevents the vessel from trading, charterers may consider CII when selecting tonnage, while owners must assess how employment patterns and operating instructions influence future ratings. The commercial effect depends on market conditions and contractual requirements rather than any automatic freight or hire penalty imposed by IMO.

BIMCO’s CII Operations Clause for Time Charter Parties 2022 provides a mechanism for owners and charterers to agree on carbon-intensity performance and manage employment instructions that could jeopardise the agreed target, where the clause is incorporated and its conditions apply. The commercial decisions influencing a vessel’s CII may therefore become a source of contractual negotiation. A rating affected by cargo nominations, voyage instructions or port delays can subsequently influence how the same vessel is assessed for future employment, even though the calculation does not directly account for the cargo transported.

The commercial value of improving carbon-intensity performance also influences investment in fuel-saving technology, a consideration examined in our earlier analysis of Flettner rotors in shipping.

CII estimates are incorporated into commercial voyage assessments, connecting carbon performance with fixture decisions.

What the current IMO review could change

The International Chamber of Shipping questioned the maximum-deadweight proxy and treatment of ballast voyages in its MEPC 84 submission. IMO Resolution MEPC.412(84), adopted in May 2026, retained capacity multiplied by distance for attained CII, while allowing actual transport-work data from the expanded Data Collection System to be considered during the second phase of the review.

Actual transport-work reporting became mandatory in 2026 for ships subject to CII, but using that information in a common rating still raises trade-specific verification and allocation questions.

Ahead of MEPC 85 (30 November to 3 December 2026), BIMCO and other organisations proposed recalibrating reference lines using fuel consumed while ships are under way, addressing distortions from port waiting. The proposal remains unadopted and would not itself replace certified capacity with actual cargo work.

Industry submissions seek changes to CII methodology, including how ballast voyages and non-sailing periods affect ratings.

The DeepDraft view

Deadweight remains a practical basis for a global rating, while replacing it entirely with actual cargo quantities would introduce commercial and verification complications. Yet the grade can influence chartering decisions despite omitting the cargo transported. Owners, charterers and financiers should therefore consider absolute CO₂ emissions, actual transport work and operating conditions alongside CII. As IMO reviews the expanded transport-work data, the objective should be to supplement the statutory rating rather than treat it as a complete assessment of transport efficiency.


Sources reviewed

  1. IMO Resolution MEPC.412(84), amendments to operational CII calculation guidelines, May 2026.
  2. IMO Resolution MEPC.353(78), CII reference lines.
  3. IMO Resolution MEPC.354(78), operational CII rating boundaries.
  4. IMO Resolution MEPC.400(83), CII reduction factors.
  5. IMO MEPC.1/Circ.684, voluntary EEOI guidelines.
  6. ICS, MEPC 84/6/13, CII data collection and identified limitations.
  7. Panagakos et al., Sustainability, 2019, empirical comparison of dry-bulk carbon-efficiency indicators.
  8. BIMCO, CII Operations Clause for Time Charter Parties 2022, charterparty arrangements relating to CII.
  9. BIMCO, 6 November 2026, proposed reassessment of CII reference lines.